Eagle Water Company Lawsuit
RE: TRIAL DATE SET
In November of 2019 Fourth District Court Judge Steven Hippler set a trial date for the lawsuit. The trial will start April 13, 2021, and is expected to last 10 days.
October 18, 2019
RE: JUDGE DENIES MOTION TO DISMISS THE CITY OF EAGLE’S LAWSUIT AGAINST EAGLE WATER COMPANY
The Ada County District Court issued its decision today denying the Motion to Dismiss the City of Eagle’s Complaint, filed last February against Eagle Water Company. The City filed suit to enforce its Right of First Refusal to purchase the water system owned and controlled by Eagle Water. The Court soundly rejected arguments made by Eagle Water, and joined by Suez, that the Right of First Refusal was not enforceable based on the statute of frauds. The lawsuit will now go forward, assuming Eagle Water continues its refusal to honor its obligations under the Right of First Refusal. The City will continue to vigorously pursue the opportunity provided by the Right of First Refusal to purchase Eagle Water, ultimately allowing our citizens the vote to make that happen. A copy of the Court’s Decision is on our website. This is a significant step forward for the City of Eagle and its citizens. We will keep you advised of future developments in the lawsuit.
February 27, 2019
RE: CITY’S RESPONSE TO LAWSUIT AGAINST EAGLE WATER COMPANY
The City filed a lawsuit today against Eagle Water Company to preserve the right of our citizens to vote on whether to acquire Eagle Water’s system and water rights.
In 2008, Eagle Water contractually agreed that the City would have a Right of First Refusal to buy Eagle Water if Eagle Water received an offer from a third party. Specifically, Eagle Water was required to give the City notice of the amount and details of the offer. The City has 30 days to give notice back that it intends to match the offer.
The City must then schedule a bond election as soon as practicable thereafter to fund part or all of the purchase.
The City believes Eagle Water received an offer that triggered the Right of First Refusal. But Eagle Water did not give the City the required Notice and opportunity to purchase. In fact, the City still does not know the amount of the offer Eagle Water received from a company called H2O Solutions.
The purpose of the lawsuit it to enforce the City’s contract rights.
The complaint the City filed will be posted on the City’s website. It sets out the City’s position in detail. Of course, whether the City wins or not will be up to the courts. We believe our citizens expect the City to pursue its rights and we have done that.
We believe it is in the City’s best interests to have local control of our water, the services provided, and on a non-profit basis.
We will keep you updated through postings on the website. Now that this issue is in the courts, our lawyers have asked us not to say more than this and to refer you to the complaint that will be posted.
- 2019-01-14 Notice of Default (PDF)
- 2019-02-26 Complaint for Declaratory and other Relief (PDF)
- Press Release - Response to Eagle Water Comp Lawsuit (PDF)
- 08-14-19 News Release City of Eagle-Eagle Water Co Lawsuit Update (PDF)
- Public Records pertaining to Eagle Water Company Communications 2013-2015
- Memorandum Decision and Order on Motion to Dismiss Eagle Water Co. Lawsuit